“Where’d all the good people go?
I keep changin’ channels, I can’t see them on the TV show.â€
Jack Johnson: “Good Peopleâ€
I can think of two natural reactions to those lyrics: (A) “Yeah, people are so rude and selfish these days. There’s no chivalry or politeness. No consideration for others. Society’s going to Hell in a handbasket. And (B) “Hey, I’m good people, and so are my friends and my family. We’re here! We’re here!â€
The strange thing about it is that those reactions tend to occur simultaneously. On the one hand, society is becoming increasingly depraved, but on the other, we still feel like good people.
We take care of our kids, obey the law, pay our taxes and buy cookie dough, or magazines, or candy or whatever the neighborhood kids are selling for their school fundraiser. Our kids don’t skip school, they get decent grades, and they don’t swear (at least around adults). We may not be perfect, but there’s always some example of true depravity for us to compare ourselves to so we’ll feel better.
We’re good people. We want to believe that. We want to believe that, though we may not be a perfect example of the Christian life, God is proud of us – because we’re good. We want to believe that way we don’t have to worry. Life is hard enough without having to worry about whether or not you’re a good person. That worry is probably the reason many people accept the idea that all “good people†go to heaven.
If we’re good people we don’t have to worry. And if we don’t have to worry, that must mean we’re going to heaven. Otherwise we’d be worrying. It makes perfect sense. And as Christians we’ve had to deal with this “good sense†for a long, long time.
I always thought, as many others have, that the answer to this lies in John 14:
I am the way the truth and the life. No one comes to the father except through me. (bold and underlines mine).
Easy right? Apparently not. My father-in-law has seen the unbelievable take place in a theological reflection Bible study. This particular study was for people who wanted to be deacons. Somehow, while discussing this verse, someone spoke up saying that they think that all good people will go to heaven. My father-in-law was so astonished that he can’t relate to me the arguments, but he fought it as much as he could, but the person persisted, and even gained support. We’ve discussed the conflict as a family, and we just don’t understand. We can’t figure out an effective response.
So, I’ve decided that the only thing to do is acquiesce. I have finally given in. If you’re a good person, you will go to heaven.
Now, before you start coming after me with holy water and crucifixes (or reaching out to congratulate me on my conversion), let me explain. If you’re a good person, you’ll go to heaven. What does that mean? First, we have to define “goodâ€.
“And God saw that it was good.†This happens in each day of creation. God makes something, and sees that it is good. We’re talking about creation: the Rockies, the Grand Canyon, Mississippi River, Himalayas, Andes, the sky, the stars, lakes and oceans, birds, dogs, and fruit flies. All of creation. Every piece of it is a little miracle in its magnitude or complexity. What words describe it? Words like “amazingâ€, “awesomeâ€, and “inspiring†come to mind. But what does God think? He thinks it’s good. What about creation in its entirety? That’s very good. I added those italics for emphasis. God actually just thought “very goodâ€.
So it seems that God’s definition of “good†is a little bit different than our own. What if we used His definition in our pronouncement? If you’re a (God’s definition of) good person, you’ll go to heaven. Well that’s true. Remember Enoch? He walked with God, and then he was no more. God spirited him away to heaven. He didn’t even die. Neither did Elijah. Alright. Who were the others? Were there any? Abraham? Isaac? Jacob? Moses? Gandhi? Mother Teresa? Nope. The Bible has this to say about it:
10As it is written:
“There is no one righteous, not even one;
11there is no one who understands,
no one who seeks God.
12All have turned away,
they have together become worthless;
there is no one who does good,
not even one.”
18″There is no fear of God before their eyes.” (Romans 3)
That creates a problem, doesn’t it? For all of us who think that we just have to be good people to get to heaven, that’s pretty disheartening. This is where the worrying begins. Because if no one is good, and you have to be good to get to heaven, who’s going to make the cut?
We know that Jesus made it. Maybe if he put our names on the list, like at an exclusive restaurant or club…if he could do that we’d surely get in, right? If he went up there and told God that we’re cool, he’d be sure to open up and let us in, right? Hmm, we may be on to something.